Subscribe Today My Account Morningstar Advisor Home Page
Morningstar Advisor Magazine October/November 2009 Issue
 
Previous Posting | Main | Next Posting >
Contributors
Bill Bergman
Janet Briaud
Cathy Curtis
Michele Gambera
Kent Grealish
David Harrell
Bob Johnson
Lawrence Jones
John Rekenthaler
Carl Richards
Curtis Smith
Michael Zhuang
Topics
recession (63)
investing (56)
economy (50)
odds & ends (31)
employment (24)
financial planning (24)
markets (22)
financial crisis (21)
mutual funds (13)
inflation (11)
consumers (9)
regulation (9)
behavioral finance (8)
economics (8)
monetary policy (8)
retirement planning (8)
Berkshire Hathaway (7)
bonds (7)
AIG (4)
executive compensation (4)
real estate (4)
recovery (4)
stocks (4)
asset allocation (3)
credit (3)
currency (3)
housing (3)
media (3)
taxes (3)
banking (2)
trade (2)
401ks (1)
Goldman Sachs (1)
Pimco (1)
accounting (1)
bailout (1)
commodities (1)
credit rating (1)
exchange traded funds (1)
index funds (1)
insurance (1)
policy (1)
suitability (1)
View all posts
Blogroll
behavior gap
Calculated Risk
dshort.com
Econbrowser
InfectiousGreed
Marginal Revolution
MarketBeat
naked capitalism
Planet Money
The Becker-Posner Blog
The Big Picture
The Investment Fiduciary
Posted: by Cathy Curtis | Bio
11-03-09 | 7:29am
What Financial Planners Do

After reading the comments section of Ron Lieber's article, I agree with Carl Richards. We have to get out and tell our stories.

The level of hostility toward advisors was shocking. Phrases such as "do it yourself," "don't waste your money," "inherent conflict of interest," "rich elite," "greed," "self-serving," and "financial planning is a joke" are just a few of the choice comments. Out of 52 comments, 75% were negative, 15% were neutral or self-serving, and only 9% were positive. It's a small sample, but is this how most people see our profession?

We can start the story by talking about these points:

Financial Planners do a lot more than invest money. Financial planners help our clients get clear on where they are spending their money, and we help our clients create and stick to a budget if that is necessary. That alone can be life changing for a lot of people.

Financial planners help our clients set up and automate a savings plan. We let our clients know if they have enough insurance and whether they have the right kind of insurance to protect themselves and their family in the event of illness or death.

Financial planners advise our clients to execute wills and trusts to make sure their estates go to the right people, with the least hassle and cost. We help our clients choose the appropriate employee benefits from their company.

Financial planners help our clients identify areas where they might save on taxes, and we help them understand what they need to do to save and prepare for their retirement years.

Yes, it's true that many financial planners also invest their clients' money, but they do so while keeping in mind the client's whole financial picture. This is known in the industry as "comprehensive financial planning." For these planners, investing money is not an isolated activity, it relates to every other part of a person's financial plan. Yes, there will always be  salespeople and bad apples-- just like in every other industry. But there are many financial planners who take their fiduciary oath seriously and who, to the maximum extent possible, act in the best interests of their clients at all times.

Most financial planners know that a wide range of returns is possible and that is why asset allocation is the predominant investment strategy implemented in client's accounts.  But if a client expects perfect market timing calls from a financial planner, they will be disappointed--as were many of Lieber's readers.

I hope that the article alerted the financial planning industry and its leaders that we all need to do a better job of educating the public about our true mission, which is one of service and not one of greed.

financial crisis  | financial planning
Reader Comments (7)
November 17, 2009 11:14:55 am
Wow... 53 whole comments and 75% negative, well stop the presses, it's time to bring in Obama to mediate!

Or, we could get a more representative picture of how much good most financial planners do for their clients.
Svesan03,  Los Angeles
November 7, 2009 8:08:33 am
I think this site lays out a great case against using Financial Advisors:

http://www.saveyournestegg.com/scam.html
Birdy,  florida
November 4, 2009 8:20:25 am
Very thorough and beneficial information. With a qualified and professional financial planner people can really save and find out what works best for them. I liked how you explained the numerous options financial planners provide for people, such as choosing the right insurance and where to save on taxes.
Pro2ProNetwork,  Huntingdon Valley, PA
November 3, 2009 1:51:55 pm
A few ideas:

- Remember that aggressive, negative comments are the most prevalent on any kind of open form. Remember the town hall meetings on health care! Whew! Fear is a primary trigger and hostility and aggression naturally go together. This is worthwhile to remember on social media interactions and email work as well. In these cases the squeaky wheels are largely noise.

Note: This is often a shock for some SocMed new users and they need to be forewarned.

The hostile-aggressive, blaming, accusatory, conspiracy, etc. comments on Leiber's article were to be expected and pretty emotive rather than enlightening. No need to overreact to them as well.

- Of course, planners and advisors of all kinds add value. There is good neuro-research on this. However, listening is always more effective then telling. Also, when telling - make it a personal story. Again, the stories our minds hear best.

Finally, the biggest challenge our planner/advisor clients face is that they are often alone and isolated in providing guidance. Wealth management is becoming increasingly complex and demanding. Just keeping up with new communications technologies is daunting.

We help our clients team with attorneys, accountants, etc. so they are not alone - out on a limb.
It also gives a terrific boost to their own marketing!
(Excuse the self-serving commercial.)

Giving advice now can feel like walking into a dangerous neighborhood - don't do it alone.

Cheers
Rich and Co.,  Chicago
November 2, 2009 9:45:18 pm
AMEN Cathy! Seriously, how long do you just sit and take it on the chin?
Carl Richards,  US
November 2, 2009 8:52:26 pm
Thanks for your commentary about the public perception of planners. It's difficult to make clients face their risk tolerance and investment perspective in a realistic way. In good times, tolerance expands only to be rewarded when the market turns downward. The more you can help your clients think about when and how the money will be used, the better they can understand your approach.
Ruth Stroup,  Oakland, CA
November 2, 2009 8:09:15 pm
Well said! Our work is so much more than investing client's money. As a stock analyst in my former life, I see how different this work is than choosing good mutual funds. Most clients aren't going to see the big picture on their own, simply because they don't have the time or desire. Thanks for writing.
Carrie Tallman,  Atlanta, GA
Post a Comment
Display Name * Location*
Comment
Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.

 

Manager's View Participants

Print  |  E-mail  |  Reprints
Feed    Add to My Yahoo!
Font Size
Bookmark and Share
Send Feedback
© 2009 Morningstar. All rights reserved.
My Account |  Login | Subscribe | Site Map | Advisor Products | Media Kit | Contact Us | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | RSS | Contributors